Islam and denominations:
It has been argued by some
non-Muslim friends that there are many denominations in the religion of
Christianity yet this division in Christianity does not exceed as Shia and
Sunni bomb blasts in mosques. Why do not
Muslims have a sense of tolerance among Muslims? How could Muslim preach the world about peace,
harmony and coexistence while they do not have peace between themselves? These are some of frequently asked questions
about prevailing situations of Muslim world today. Some Christian missionary
people have been trying to create doubt and suspension about Islam with these
questions. As if Islam is religion of
violence and intolerance. Some time they take some Quranic verses out of
context in support of their arguments. Most probably they refer to actions of
Al-Qaeda and ISIS in support of their arguments.
These types of questions have been
asked many times. There is a difference between theory and practice in all
religions. Islam and Muslims are not exceptional to this generally prevailing
condition of humanity.
The religion of Christianity has been portrayed as only peaceful
religion in the world. The followers of Christianity have been portrayed as
always have been peaceful people and yet if we
read the history of Christianity we would be surprised to see how many
millions people have been killed in conflicts between Roman Catholics and
Protestants. Medieval Europe was full of religious wars between RC and
Protestants. Just read through European wars of religion to see this. The Holy
Roman Empire was full of wars for Eighty year from (1568 -1648). The French wars of religions from (1562-1598)
killed many thousands. Many wars like
these took place between different denominations of Christianity. Yet, today it
is peaceful religion of Islam has been portrayed as a religion of intolerance.
Of course there were some Shia and Sunni conflicts took place in Islamic history
as well but it was not as we have seen between Christianity.
EU history tells us how Protestants
killed millions of Roman Catholics. Moreover, how many millions were killed in
WW1 and WW 11, more than 50 Million people were killed. Who killed them? Is it
Muslims or so called Christians? How many Millions were killed by Hitler? Was
he a Muslim or a Christian? How many Millions were killed in Slave trades by
colonial powers? These so called Christians traded with slaves of Africa and
West indies. Millions people were killed in these trade on sea and land. We
cannot see that Christianity has always been peaceful religion in the past.
Consider Muslim history of Spain… What happened to Muslims in Spain?
At the end of war in Spain Christian
people gave Muslims three choices. Either to convert to Christianity or to
migrate to North Africa or otherwise, they would to be killed? This was how
Christians treated Muslims in Spain. Yet, look how Muslim treated Christians in
history. For the 1400 years Christians
and Jews have been living with Muslims in Muslim land. By law Muslims should
protect non-Muslims who live with Muslims and yet, what Christians did for
Muslim minorities in Spain and in recent time in Balkan wars. They wiped
Muslims out of their land.
This is the sense of tolerance
Christianity is preaching. Please do not
judge Islam because of the actions of some fanatics acting in the name of
Islam. After all, ISIS is a creation of America. This proxy Muslim group was
created with support of Mossad to make mayhem among Muslims.
I agree that we have some religious
dispute among Muslims but yet no way it is similar to the differences between
denominations in Christianity. Although we have differences yet we have more
similarities between us. We are united in basic doctrines of Islam. The basic
concepts such as unity of one God, one last prophet and day of judgement are
same for all Muslims. We all pray to one
God, we all face one direction in our prayer and we all follow one prophet.
Yet, see the differences in Christianity. The changed the entire concept of God
and they changed the very notion of religion.
Yes, christians fought amongst themselves, and killed thousands few hundred years back. Since, then their theologeans, preachers and public have learnt from the mistakes. Now they agree they have disagreements. They respect the rights of the people to hold different opnions. They have arrangements to coexist in a civilized manner. For example catholic pope was given rousing welcome by Chtistian President Obama and Americans. Muslim Shia and Sunni religious and poltical leaders are still vitually living in the period of Imam Hussein. Their thinking has not developed enough to guide the Shia and Sunni Umma avoid blood shed. To accept the different opnions of others, respect the right to differ, and to live together as fellow human beings in a civilized manner.
ReplyDeleteIn summary, Christians are managing their denominational differences wonderfully in a civilized manner.We Muslims are still killing each other , like the Christians of the 15th and 16th century and blaming others for our failures. This is the bitter truth.
ReplyDeleteDear Peace. I partially agree with you... That despite being the followers of a peaceful religion: Islam is the culmination of all revealed religions. Yet, we see blood bath in the name of Islam... Dear Peace it is your so called friend of Christians who created this mess. Look when AL- Mursi was elected democratically your so called Christians of western nation did all to over throw Mursi...
ReplyDeleteMoreover, You so called peace making friends of christian have done more than that.
most of these internal wars in Muslim land created by your so called friends of Christians. your name it Afghanistan, Iraq, Palestine but all man made and your christian friends are behind it... who got all mass destruction? who got most Nuclear war head? who produce all most modern weapons? please do not tell us what Christianity has done to humanity? most of missionary works converting poor in all poor countries done by tricking people into Christianity? then you called them they have created peace. When more one million people killed in Central Africa ( Congo) where have been these peace loving Christian friends? it is because they are black they do not deserve to be living? so many examples we have today?
But you should know well external forces have been meddling in.Muslims land for long time..when King Faisal oppose them.they killed him
ReplyDeletewhen Sadam oppposed them they killed him..
it is people who should make a revolutionary stuggle
..
look at leaders of Muslim land...when
கட்டுரையாசிரியர் ஷியாக்கள் இஸ்லாத்தின் அங்கம் என்று சொல்கின்றாரா? இல்லை என்று சொல்கின்றாரா?
ReplyDeleteஇது தமிழ் தளம் தானே? தமிழில் எழுதினால் தானே எல்லோருக்கும் நல்லது?
Why do not read it? There was one more article about shia and sunni conflict. ..please go through it...
ReplyDelete